A break clause can be one of the most valuable rights in a commercial lease. It lets a tenant (and sometimes a landlord) end the lease early on a set date. But break clauses are often conditional, and dilapidations are one of the most common reasons a tenant’s break goes wrong. If a condition is not met, the break can fail and the tenant may remain bound by the lease, including the rent, for the rest of the term.
This guide explains how break clauses and dilapidations interact in England and Wales, what tenants need to do before a break date, and what landlords can still claim once a break has taken effect. It is general guidance, not legal advice. The exact wording of your lease is what counts, so take legal advice on any break you are planning to exercise.
Conditional and unconditional break clauses
An unconditional break only requires the right notice to be served in the right way and at the right time. A conditional break adds requirements the tenant must satisfy, often by the break date itself. Common conditions include:
- Serving a valid break notice within the notice period, on the correct party and in the form the lease requires
- Paying the rent and sometimes other sums such as service charge and insurance up to the break date
- Giving vacant possession of the premises on the break date
- Complying with the tenant’s covenants, which can include repair, redecoration and reinstatement obligations
Courts tend to treat break conditions strictly. If the lease says a condition must be met by the break date, coming close is usually not enough. That is why early planning matters so much.
Where dilapidations can trip up a break
Compliance with repairing covenants
Some older leases make the break conditional on the tenant having complied with all of its covenants, including repair. Strict compliance of this kind can be very hard to achieve in practice, because almost any outstanding item of disrepair could technically be a breach. Some leases soften this with wording such as “material compliance”, but what counts as material is still open to argument. Tenants with this type of condition should treat dilapidations as a break issue, not just an end-of-lease cost.
Vacant possession
Vacant possession is a frequent break condition. Broadly, the landlord must be able to take immediate and exclusive possession, free of people and of anything that substantially interferes with its use of the property. In Riverside Park Ltd v NHS Property Services Ltd [2016] EWHC 1313 (Ch), the High Court held that a tenant had failed to give vacant possession because it left demountable partitioning in place, which the court treated as chattels that substantially interfered with the landlord’s possession. The tenant’s break failed and it remained liable under the lease.
The practical lesson is that leaving behind partitioning, furniture, equipment or stored items can put a break at risk, even if the tenant has moved out. Whether alterations should be stripped out or left in place depends on the lease, any licence for alterations and the condition itself, so get advice on this point well before the break date.
Paying sums due
If the break is conditional on payment of rent, tenants should check whether a full quarter’s rent falls due before the break date. In Marks and Spencer plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust Company (Jersey) Ltd [2015] UKSC 72, the Supreme Court refused to imply a term requiring the landlord to refund rent paid in advance for the period after the break date. Unless the lease says otherwise, the tenant may need to pay the full quarter to satisfy the condition and may not get the balance back.
Looking for experienced, professional commercial property surveyors?
Fill in your details and we'll give you a call.
GET IN TOUCHWhat type of survey or report do you require?
Please enter the location details of the property you'd like surveyed.
For Employer's Agent please enter the project location.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Please enter the value of the project you require an Employer's Agent for.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Please enter the size of the property you would like surveyed.
Fill in your details below to get your instant quote.
Fill in your details below to get your instant quote.
By clicking below you are agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Summary
| Description | Information | Quantity | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discount : | |||
| Total : | |||
Planning ahead: a practical approach for tenants
Tenants who want to rely on a break should start preparing well in advance of the deadline for serving notice. A sensible approach includes:
- Read the break clause and the repairing covenants together, along with any licences for alterations and any schedule of condition attached to the lease. A schedule of condition can limit what the tenant has to put back.
- Commission an early dilapidations assessment so you know what the lease may require and how long the works would take. A delap survey gives you an item-by-item view of likely liabilities before the landlord produces its own schedule.
- Decide whether to do the works or negotiate a settlement. Where the break is conditional on compliance, doing the works may be the safer route. Where it is not, a negotiated payment can sometimes be more cost-effective.
- Plan the strip-out and vacating with vacant possession in mind, including removing stored items and checking what alterations must be reinstated.
- Keep a record of the condition of the premises at the break date, with photographs and a written report.
If time allows, some tenants ask the landlord to agree in writing that specific conditions have been met, or to accept a payment in place of works. Any such agreement should be properly documented.
What landlords can still claim after a break
A valid break ends the lease, but it does not wipe out the tenant’s liability for breaches of covenant up to that date. A landlord can still bring a dilapidations claim, and the Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a Tenancy (the Dilapidations Protocol) applies to terminal claims in the usual way.
Under the Protocol, the landlord’s schedule should generally be sent within 56 days after the tenancy ends, together with a quantified demand. The tenant should usually respond within 56 days of receiving the quantified demand. Our guide to the Dilapidations Protocol explains each stage in more detail.
Damages for disrepair are also usually capped by section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 at the amount by which the disrepair has reduced the value of the landlord’s interest. This can be lower than the cost of the works, particularly if the landlord plans to refurbish or redevelop.
Advice for landlords
For landlords, a tenant’s break notice is a signal to start preparing. Check the break conditions and whether they appear to have been met, inspect the premises before the break date, and instruct a surveyor to prepare a terminal schedule promptly once the lease ends. If the break may fail, take legal advice before accepting the keys or acting in a way that could be treated as accepting the lease has ended.
Break clause and dilapidations FAQs
Does a successful break mean I have no dilapidations liability?
No. The break ends the lease, but the landlord can usually still claim damages for breaches that existed on the break date.
Can I negotiate a cash settlement instead of doing the works?
Often yes, but if your break is conditional on compliance with repairing covenants, a settlement should be agreed and documented before the break date so the condition is not left open to dispute.
When should I instruct a surveyor?
As early as possible, ideally before you serve the break notice, so there is time to carry out works or agree terms.
Get help with dilapidations before your break date
Whether you are a tenant preparing to exercise a break or a landlord responding to one, an experienced dilapidations surveyor can assess liabilities, prepare or respond to a schedule and support negotiations. We connect landlords and tenants with surveyors across the UK, including for a schedule of dilapidations in London. Get your commercial building surveyor quote in under 60 seconds and we will take it from there.

