If a commercial lease is coming to an end, or has just ended, the word “protocol” is likely to come up quickly. The Dilapidations Protocol sets the steps and timescales that landlords and tenants in England and Wales are expected to follow before a dilapidations claim ever reaches court. Knowing how it works helps landlords put together a claim that stands up, and helps tenants avoid paying for more than the lease actually requires.

Here’s how it works, stage by stage.

What is the Dilapidations Protocol?

Its full name is the Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a Tenancy. It forms part of the Civil Procedure Rules and applies to commercial property in England and Wales. It covers terminal dilapidations claims, meaning claims for damages made against a tenant at the end of a tenancy.

The Protocol does not tell you what “repair”, “reinstatement” or “redecoration” means. That depends on the wording of your lease and any related documents such as licences for alterations. What it does is set out the conduct a court would normally expect before proceedings start: a reasonable timetable for exchanging information, standards for the schedule and the claim, and an expectation that both sides genuinely try to settle without going to court.

Because it deals with claims at the end of a lease, the Protocol does not strictly govern interim schedules served part-way through a term. If you’re not sure which type of schedule you’re dealing with, see our guide to interim vs terminal schedules of dilapidation.

The Dilapidations Protocol step by step

1. The landlord serves a schedule of dilapidations

The landlord sends the tenant a schedule setting out what it considers to be the breaches of the lease, the work needed to remedy each one and, where relevant, its costings. Breaches should be grouped into categories such as repair, reinstatement and redecoration, and the schedule should refer to the lease clause each item relates to.

The schedule should be sent within a reasonable time, which the Protocol says will generally be within 56 days after the tenancy ends. A landlord can send a schedule before the lease ends, but at termination it should either confirm the position is unchanged or send an updated schedule.

2. The schedule is endorsed

The schedule must be endorsed by the landlord or, where a surveyor has prepared it, by the landlord’s surveyor. The endorsement confirms that:

  • all the works listed are reasonably required to remedy the breaches;
  • full account has been taken of the landlord’s intentions for the property; and
  • any costings are reasonable.

A surveyor endorsing a schedule should have regard to the RICS guidance on dilapidations. The endorsement is a professional statement, not a negotiating position.

3. The landlord sends a quantified demand

Alongside the schedule (and within the same timescale), the landlord sends a quantified demand. This sets out the sum claimed as damages and any other losses, such as lost rent, explains the legal basis for each, and confirms whether VAT applies. Where the figure is based on the cost of works, it should be backed by an invoice or a detailed estimate.

Two points in the Protocol matter a great deal here. The demand should be limited to the landlord’s likely loss, which is not necessarily the same as the cost of the works. And it should not include work that is likely to be superseded by the landlord’s own plans for the building, for example where it intends to strip out or redevelop.

4. The tenant responds

The tenant should respond within a reasonable time, which will usually be within 56 days after the landlord sends the quantified demand. Where possible the response should be set out in the landlord’s own schedule, item by item, so both sides’ views sit side by side (often called a Scott schedule).

The tenant’s response is also endorsed, either by the tenant or by its surveyor, confirming the works it accepts are all that were reasonably required, that its costs are reasonable, and that it has taken account of what it reasonably believes the landlord’s intentions to be. If the tenant thinks items will be superseded by the landlord’s plans, it should say so and give the evidence it relies on. Our guide on what to do if you’re served with a schedule of dilapidation covers the practical first steps.

5. Meeting and negotiation

The parties and their surveyors are encouraged to meet before the tenant’s response is due, and should generally meet within 28 days after the tenant sends its response. These meetings are without prejudice, and the aim is to agree as many items as possible.

6. Alternative dispute resolution

Both sides should consider whether mediation or another form of alternative dispute resolution would be more suitable than going to court. The Protocol is clear that litigation should be a last resort, and that a court can take compliance with the Protocol into account when deciding who pays costs. No one can be forced to mediate, but ignoring the option altogether carries risk.

7. Quantifying the loss before proceedings

Before issuing proceedings, the landlord should give the tenant a detailed breakdown of its loss, based on a formal diminution valuation, actual spend on works, or both. If the tenant runs a diminution defence, it should provide its own valuation, generally within 56 days of that breakdown. A final stocktake then asks both sides to narrow the issues before anyone goes to court.

Section 18 and why the repair bill isn’t always the claim

The Protocol’s focus on “likely loss” ties in with Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927. This caps damages for breach of a repairing covenant at the amount by which the value of the landlord’s interest in the property has been reduced by the disrepair. It also provides that no damages are recoverable for failing to leave premises in repair if the building would be demolished, or structurally altered in a way that makes those repairs valueless, at or shortly after the end of the lease.

In practice this means a schedule priced at the full cost of works is only the starting point. What the landlord can actually recover may be lower, and the landlord’s intentions for the building can make a real difference.

Practical tips for landlords and tenants

  • Start early. Looking at dilapidations well before lease end leaves time to plan works or a settlement rather than reacting to deadlines.
  • Gather the documents. The lease, any licences for alterations and any schedule of condition attached to the lease all shape what is and isn’t owed.
  • Keep the timetable in view. Diary the 56-day and 28-day points as soon as a schedule or quantified demand arrives.
  • Be realistic about intentions. Plans to refurbish, re-let or redevelop can supersede items on a schedule, so both sides should be open about them.

Dilapidations Protocol FAQs

Is the Dilapidations Protocol compulsory?

It isn’t a statute, but it sets out the conduct the court normally expects before proceedings begin. The court can take non-compliance into account, including when deciding costs, so in practice both sides should follow it.

Can a landlord serve a schedule before the lease ends?

Yes. If it does, it should confirm at termination that the position is unchanged, or send a further schedule within a reasonable time.

Do I need a surveyor?

The Protocol still applies if you don’t use one. However, the endorsements, costings and item-by-item responses it expects are the day-to-day work of a dilapidations surveyor.

Get help with a dilapidations claim

Whether you’re a landlord preparing a terminal schedule or a tenant who has just received one, an experienced commercial building surveyor can take you through each stage of the Protocol. We connect landlords and tenants with surveyors across the UK, including for a schedule of dilapidations in London. Get a quote for your dilapidation survey in under a minute and we’ll take it from there.